Why matlab is better than c

Other than linear algebra routines, the performance is generally bad. Question for Mathworks engineers: When Matlab code is fully vectorized, one of the performance limiting factor is the matrix indexing operation. Improve this answer. Community Bot 1 1 1 silver badge. Thats a beautiful summary. And that made me too curious to find who is this amazing PhD guy from Cornell, but "Apparently, this user prefers to keep an air of mystery about them".

For over 2 years ever since I asked this Q. Thats no problem, to respect privacy. Thank you! I am very glad to help, and share my hard learned lessons in the past.

Point 3. Show 6 more comments. Thanks for the answer. But given all that wisdom of matlab and Fortran level of optimization, why should matlab be slower! I mean, is n't it a wasted effort to optimize at assembly level, if you don't see any improvement? Also, though I see your point, "strongly depends on your coding style" is something that needs some elaboration.

I would actually request, to consider a reasonable programming efficiency in both sides, which still has this x range of difference. The point is: Matlab is very fast for some large operations matrix and lin. The problems Matlab is optimised for are those where the workload is in large matrix and linear algebra operations with little slow boilerplate code around. If your problem is not of that kind i. This is where the division between the fast, optimised and the scripting part of the language comes from.

I agree with DCS - its all about how you code. I see much code written in Matlab that does not make use of built in functions and that is not vectorized. Do these two things and it runs pretty damn fast. Add a comment. Omar Essilfie-Quaye 55 5 5 bronze badges. Fabio Veronese Fabio Veronese 6, 2 2 gold badges 15 15 silver badges 27 27 bronze badges. Jonas Jonas 74k 10 10 gold badges silver badges bronze badges.

I think you can consider the difference in four folds at least. Compiled vs Interpreted Strongly-typed vs Dynamically-typed Performance vs Fast-prototyping Special strength For can be easily generalized into comparison between two family of programming languages. It is a difficult quesion after all. Ray Ray 2, 16 16 silver badges 21 21 bronze badges.

AndyZe AndyZe 39 4 4 bronze badges. Alex Granit Alex Granit 21 2 2 bronze badges. Sign up or log in Sign up using Google. Sign up using Facebook. Sign up using Email and Password. Afshin Ahmadi on 29 Dec Thank you James. The authors do mention vectorized MATLAB code, but at the same time admit that the algorithm they chose for comparison purposes is not very good for the types of vectorization that MATLAB can provide for other algorithms presumably because of the short-circuit potential.

So yeah, if you pick an algorithm that is not good at vectorization within what MATLAB provides, it is not surprising that it is 9 to 11 times slower. I'm surprised the number isn't even higher than that, quite frankly. Thanks so much for your insights. I appreciate you taking the time to help me. Image Analyst on 29 Dec Vote 1. Imagine if you had to write and validate your own code for regionprops or bwconncomp!!

It would take a very long time and pure speed tests on simple benchmarks don't take that into account. So cherry picking situations a simple situation where MATLAB is slower like using a loop when it could be vectorized is not a fair comparison in my opinion. My programs are typically to lines of code, with extensive use of built-in functions. If I had to write all those functions myself, or even use open source functions, it would take much longer and that development time is not taken into account in a pure speed test done after all code writing has been finished.

I totally agree with you. See Also. Tags performance vectorization high performance solvers. Release Ra. Start Hunting! An Error Occurred Unable to complete the action because of changes made to the page. Matlab is a programming language that is used for computing the technical algorithms which were released in by Mathworks. It consists of the computation, programming, and visualization to generate the easy to use situations where the issues and solutions are represented like a mathematical notation.

This language is an expansion of the C language; therefore, it is quite attainable to code it as other C languages. If you find any difficulty related to Matlab assignments, then you can use our service on Matlab assignment help to resolve all the difficulties. Then press enter and it will show the output as.